Jan 28
Piracy
           It is important for people to first understand that there is a fine distinction to be made between the pirating of digital content and theft itself. Despite the message of those commercials before movies and the fiery rhetoric of industry leaders, piracy is not the same as theft. I will use a simple example to demonstrate the difference. If I go into a clothing store and take a pair of jeans without paying for them, that is theft. I have not only taken a product without compensating them for it, but I have also deprived them of the ability to sell that pair of jeans to a legitimate customer. If instead I went into that same store with a magic pants copying machine, copied the jeans and left without compensating the store that would be more akin to piracy. Now the comparison isn’t exactly perfect with intellectual property like games and media, but the main point remains. Theft is depriving a seller of a legitimate sale, whereas piracy is not. While that doesn’t make media piracy legally or morally acceptable, it remains an important to understand that difference. Whenever game companies make statements about their content being pirated they consider the illegal downloads as theft, as if they were discs swiped from store shelves or if cash had been heisted from their coffers. While these unauthorized downloads are unfortunate, those pirated games are not directly taking money from the game developer and publisher.
Don’t get me wrong, I understand that people who create content deserve compensation for their work. Game developers should be paid for the games they create. The problem is that already many consumers are able to buy games without a single cent going back to the respective creators. Have you ever used an EB/Gamestop Edge Card? How about an import from eBay? Ever bought a game from the classifieds or a garage sale? If you can answer yes to any of those questions, then you bought a game without compensating the developers. While this seems obvious when you think about it, I want you to really dwell on that fact. Look at the shelves of your local EB or Gamestop the next time you are in a mall. Think about how many games you or others have bought used in order to save some money. While those may be legitimate retail transactions, when it comes to the developers there is no difference between those purchases and someone going to The Pirate Bay.
Whenever torrenting and piracy is discussed there is always that quick assumption that the only advantage to these networks is that the content is free. While that benefit is undeniable, the other advantages of torrent networks are often overlooked. Torrent sites are incredibly robust distribution services. They are convenient, accessible through any computer with an internet connection. They are also relatively fast, capable of delivering the largest games and entire seasons of television shows in a matter of hours. They also have an absurdly wide selection. To my knowledge there is no store on the planet which has the same digital collection available that Isohunt does. And while Isohunt may be peddling illegal content it is in many cases the most convenient, or only way to get access to the games you want.
           I’m going to illustrate this point with a personal example. One of my favourite games is Grim Fandango. I bought a copy when it came out back in 98 and I thoroughly enjoyed my time in the
- There aren’t many copies of this game left for sale.
- Those that are left cost at least $80, before shipping.
Now, I really like Grim Fandango, but there are limits to my love. I am not the type of guy who will pay $80 for a replacement copy of a game. It is an especially uncomfortable option when all of this money is going to some gouging collector as opposed to the people who actually worked on the game. Out of curiosity I checked Isohunt.com. The first page of search results was filled with torrents that would provide the replacement I wanted. In a few moments, I threw morality to the wind by clicking the download link and installing uTorrent. Within a few hours I was once again beginning a four year adventure with Manny Calavera. I pirated Grim Fandango. And ya know what? I think it was a totally reasonable and justifiable choice.
           Now I understand that this is a pretty specific example, but there are a few wider and more salient points to be wrought from my struggle. First off, the present gaming marketplace makes it very hard to compensate the game developer for their work. While the marketplace for purchasing older games is improving with storefronts like Steam, Direct2Drive and Gametap, there remain a lot of titles which manage to slip through the cracks. And this is occurring on the PC platform, the most open platform of all. Good luck trying to find a new copy of a console game that is 6 months old that doesn’t begin with Halo or Grand Theft Auto. Once a console games printing is finished, that pretty much puts a wrap on any revenue a developer expects to see from a title. Once there are no new discs to be sold, there is no way for the developer to get money from retail stores. Now again, this is improving with the advent of digital catalogues on the Playstation Network Store and the Xbox Live Marketplace, but the vast majority of console titles remain available solely on disc.
           Just for fun, I’ll indulge you with another example. One of my friends is a fan of the Earthbound series. He is one of many dedicated fans who for years has wanted an English translation of the last game in the series, Mother 3. Despite numerous petitions and great deal of community support, Nintendo showed nothing but apathy towards these demands. Eventually there was a successful fan-made translation project which acted in Nintendo’s place. However, the only way to distribute this translation was through a downloadable DS Game ROM and the use of an R4 card. In other words, in order to play the game, you would need to pirate the game and use a device that is considered criminal in Japan.
           The major point I’m trying to get across here is that a great deal of piracy occurs for reasons beyond the content being free. A lot of it takes place because of inadequacies in the distribution of games to begin with. Limited downloadable catalogues, locking games to certain regions, or plain laziness from publishers leads people to choose torrenting as a solution. While this certainly doesn’t account for or justify a great deal of the piracy that occurs, the presence of torrent networks shouldn’t be universally derided. In fact, the games industry should attempt to learn from them.
           Digital piracy has pushed other industries into embracing new directions. Just look at the music industry. Before there was iTunes, there was Napster. If peer-to-peer services were used only because the content was free, then iTunes should have been a financial flop. The illegal availability of music online forced the recording industry to adopt digital distribution. Gaming is no different. Before Steam there were Warez sites or other illegal options. Piracy has preceded and pioneered digital distribution for multiple mediums. And despite their constant presence, legitimate options have managed to flourish regardless. While I am perfectly savvy enough to torrent any game imaginable, I have still spent about $400 on my Steam account. The undeniable success of services like Steam should be an indicator to the rest of the games industry of how consumers are willing to make the transition to a fully digital store. Publishers ought to embrace this paradigm shift rather than stick to relics of the past like region locking, limited printings or fixed pricing. Piracy has shown the gaming industry that their customers still have an interest in buying older and more obscure titles, or are willing to sacrifice a physical copy in favour of convenience. Developers shouldn’t allow a games distribution or revenue to be dictated by retailers and disc pressers. It is the limitations of the retail model which allow piracy to exist. If game makers want to stop illegal downloading, they need to provide an alternative at the very least.
7 Comments so far
Leave a comment
[…] Read more from the original source: j.w.gettys » Piracy […]
[…] link: j.w.gettys » Piracy Share and […]
You raise very strong arguments for vintage titles, and I am *very* excited that they are starting to show up in digital distribution streams. However, I don’t think its this kind of pirating that gets on developer’s nerves. The current Assassin’s Creed “scandal” is hilarious to watch from the sidelines though. Hilarious and sad.
I’m also curious who is actually getting the money for some of these older titles. Intellectual property tends to change hands often when examined on these kind of time-frames.
How much is the X-COM pack currently priced on steam? On “this side of the pond” it costs 8.99GBP and steam really doesn’t want me to purchase it as a Canadian… If I were to give you my infos do ya think you could act as my power of attorney? email me regardless, we havn’t talked in forever.
[…] 1234567891011121314151617181920212223Chevy Cavalier Auto Parts Cold Air Intake, King Charles Cavalier Puppies Sale LiverpoolChevy Cavalier Auto Parts Cold Air Intake, King Charles Cavalier Puppies Sale Liverpoolbuy used cavalier chevrolet g3500 cavalier part journals 1996 cavalier head gasket cavalier hood my chevy cavalier king charles spaniel puppies sale essex price cavalier king charles spaniel chevy cavalier tail prices chevrolet cavalier parts discount cavalier king charles puppies sale hertfordshire west yorkshire owners manual 1995 chevrolet cavalier haynes 2001 cavalier abs light trac off 2003 cavalier ls cleveland cavaliers price get buy chevrolet cavalier cowl induction discount 2000 chevrolet cavalier hood hinge capa certified san antonio spurs vs cleveland cavaliers nba finals used cavalier z24 g3500 chevrolet aveo5 king charles cavalier breeders australia systems cavalier exhaust system t304 stainless steel 2000 silver cavalier chevrolet cavalier 3 parts find cavalier cleveland cavs b pontiac b sunfire b radiator b chevrolet cavalier aftermarket parts chevrolet cavalier cold air intake cheap cleveland cavaliers basketball tickets cavalier parts body kits grilles cavalier dictionary cav english poets cavalier king charles spaniels co uk used chevrolet cavalier convertibles car prices 98 cavalier alternator cavalier hard change brakes cavalier 1995 chevy cavalier body kits firenza sale vauxhall cavalier astra nova wings west body kit cavalier 2002 chevy cavalier check engine light battery cavalier headlights free shipping cavalier king charles american kennel club pedigree c2500 used cavalier chevrolet monte carlo cavalier distributor last minute cavalier parts cavalier tail lights mickey change brakes chevy cavalier 02 chevy cavalier specs cavalier parts radiator support 2001 cavalier service light come coolant 2004 chevrolet cavalier strut assembly cavalier king charles spaniel puppies sale liverpool dogue de bordeaux headlight 2002 chevy cavalier performance cavalier king charles puppies for sale 2000 cavalier abs light cavalier factory built homes emf discount 1988 cadillac chevy cavalier cavalier alternator price 02 headlight 2005 chevrolet cavalier order chevrolet cavalier cavalier rent used chevrolet dealers cleveland cavaliers contact quicken changing spark plug wires 1995 chevy cavalier cleveland cavaliers sale spaniel dogs 2000 cavalier problems water pump cavalier halo headlight bulbs radiator 1994 cavalier chevy beretta fuel pump cavalier window motor replacement cavalier antiques fine furniture cleveland cavaliers server convertible 1999 chevrolet cavalier z24 chevrolet cavalier mods exhaust 2002 radiator 1994 chevrolet cavalier cleveland cavaliers supercharger cavalier king charles seattle lx sport 2001 chevrolet cavalier cleveland cavaliers dog collar 2002 chevrolet cavalier information 2002 cavalier aftermarket parts autos 2002 chevrolet cavalier cavalier king charles spaniel puppies sale 1991 cavalier parts 1995 cavalier ls 1998 cavalier thermostat cavalier ls sport clips find chevrolet cavalier ii cavalier instructions tal sale cavalier 98 accesorios colorado chevrolet cavalier cavalier create 2000 cavalier accessories mud flaps z24 engine 2002 chevrolet cavalier cavalier headlight discount lamp chevrolet cavalier replacement 2 door 2000 cavalier performance cavalier ground effect cleveland cavaliers bulb headlight assembly chevrolet cavalier parts front bumper aftermarket chevy cavalier etc light lebron james cavaliers chevy cavalier tail light bulb replacement convertible price 1997 chevrolet cavalier cavalier dog names king charles spaniel breeders 2001 chevy cavalier specs Cadillac Cts Bulb | Rx7 Stats Mazda | Low Raider Bike | Astro Van Forum | Spare Tire Chevy | […]
[…] 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748Relay 1 Sale Side Jedec Standard, Saturn Relay 3 Taillight Replacement Tail LightRelay 1 Sale Side Jedec Standard, Saturn Relay 3 Taillight Replacement Tail Lightrelay 3 aftermarket sleep fuse panel relay 1 cheap brand 2007 saturn relay 1 launched 1964 summer olympics ses americom relay 1 pneumatic 53w 5 relay 24vdc relay rack history car relay radiator fan alstom motor protection relay 10 relay headlight saturn sc1 power relay rm 2 3 7 home depot fan relay relay 1 factory single time delay saturn relay 2 headlight weathertech 6 volt headlight relay 1 discount eagle ford saturn relay buick dmx relay kit xlr plug saturn relay 3 control relay coil design magnetic flux relay 3 free components 1 part saturn relay tail light assembly dot and sae approved relay 2 coupon replacement saturn relay 3i mpg mercury mountaineer headlamp relay relay 3 buy front fender relay 1 oem circuit air conditioning relay 1 used brand relay 2 promo process relay 2 radiator bolts flex a lite electric fan relay 2 replacement kool vue heated wiring a 3 phase relay overload 144 relay replacement headlight volvo s70 relay 3 apartments may relay 3 sound output relay 1 broiler frigidaire range pam 2 relay wire nuts double sided tape relay outdoor advertising relay lighting control relay 3 part compare prices integer 2 radiator fan assembly fuel pump relay flex a lite relay 1 oem air dryer toyota efi relay relay 2 coupon app boiler relay stuck relay 2 price sold radio slave ford abs relay 2 pole contactor relay wiring ac dual relay headlight bulb relay gare part dieu relay 1 radiator 1997 dodge grand caravan pop rivets relay jr adoption relay 1 amazon hid relay manual relay 1 auto saturn l300 relay 1 discount oem acura jv relay 1 form a relay 1 baseboard tamper programmable line voltage thermostat aa relay cover 3 phase relay acrobat 2 coolant saturn relay 12 volt latching relay volvo google replacement fuel pump relay relay 2 mass cv 5 relay relay 1 dvd jeep grand cherokee relay panel relay 1 full run half marathon solid state relay radiator fan discount aftermarket prices relay 2 saturn lw300 relay 3 boiler wiring diagram duramax glow plug relay relay 2 coupon ebay 1 boiler zone valve switching relays relay headlight buy toyota solid state relay bulb wiring harness relay 3 sale 4rd relay iii discount low price schneider synch check relay transmission line relay body parts citroen relay van relay 2 discount process relay 2 radiator service is my exchange server a spam relay relay 3 promotion front fender motorcycle 2 sale interior exterior color 2005 saturn relay opel astra headlight relay pt 775 relay relay 1 marketing eagle ford 1 discount asics x 100m relay athletics relay 2 auction interior shocks nissan fuel pump relay relay 3 tour schedule 1 added mail smtp relay server 2 2005 saturn relay car parts chevy volt relay 1 wall 110 hurdles relay 3 substitute mirror 2 form solid state relays celebrity blower relay mechanical rf relay saturn relay 1 parts replacement mirror oxygen sensor diode over relay voltage rating Gs430 Parts Orders | 350sdl Used New | Oldsmobile Omega Cars | P2500 Video Cvs | Radiator Aftermarket Mitsubishi | […]
[…] 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100101102103104105106Pb200 Part Gran Fury Voyager Ex, Reliant Parts Gran Fury Grand Voyager Plymouth Caravelle - 139.an74.comPb200 Part Gran Fury Voyager Ex, Reliant Parts Gran Fury Grand Voyager Plymouth Caravellechrysler cirrus locator grand voyager voyager env2 chrysler voyager motor geht aftermarket headlights plymouth voyager brake pads kalkhoff voyager 2007 star trek voyager armor 1986 kawasaki voyager repair manual plymouth voyager aftermarket wheel covers 2000 voyager xii radiator head gasket plymouth grand voyager pb250 2nd hand plymouth grand voyager buy chrysler cirrus grand voyager grand voyager engine light trouble codes oem replacement carpet voyager plymouth valiant voyager boiler ssvh storage tanks voyager trike kit forum tow pac plymouth voyager replacement oxygen sensor voyager 220 manual aspen sale used classified chrysler grand voyager cubiertas grand voyager barracuda buy used grand voyager lg voyager titanium cover voyager spacecraft bach chrysler voyager gpl voyager caretaker part i scott jaeck 1996 plymouth voyager belt replacement voyager custom ringtones verizon voyager spa replacement parts voyager 15 10 voyager titanium review cell phone voyager high quality aftermarket radiator support 2001 chrysler voyager check engine light voyager review verizon wireless ev do chrysler lhs grand voyager pt cruiser carmax plymouth voyager arrow used plymouth grand voyager barbara kruger replacement grand voyager 1999 plymouth voyager parts dodge grand caravan eagle talon discount grand voyager trailduster discount voyager plymouth turismo corsair flash voyager cmfusb2 0 16gb review 1995 plymouth voyager forum parkers grand voyager acclaim headlight plymouth grand voyager change transmission fluid plymouth grand voyager 1986 radiator 1989 plymouth voyager coolant chrysler voyager thermostat gasket voyager synthesizer voyager codes any coupon lg voyager charger problems 1992 grand voyager recalls part voyager performance free shipping air intake 300m headlight grand voyager chrysler lebaron chrysler voyager anno 2003 dodge caravans pb350 part dealers grand voyager craigslist search grand voyager 1999 plymouth grand voyager expresso voyager season star trek tc lamborghini aftermarket grand voyager voyager refurb usb flash drive 1989 voyager parts plymouth prowler plymouth pb250 cheap voyager metrologic voyager driver aftermarket way pb150 plymouth grand voyager substitute headlight assembly chrysler voyager voyager teacup voyager verizon lg cell phone accessories voyager jacket with chrysler voyager for sale nz people mover voyager day voyager half klingon voyager bumper capa certified fog light chrysler voyager 2 1995 chrysler cirrus salvage yards grand voyager 2000 chrysler voyager for sale dodge caravan will lg voyager stores voyager size aftermarket chrysler voyager air deflector brake rotors voyager scorpion part ii nine unimatrix zero voyager catalog mtsu chrysler voyager engine noise voyager early cooling system pb350 voyager plymouth trailduster voyager san 1997 plymouth voyager service manual rachael taylor voyager 1998 plymouth grand voyager window switch voyager metro edition input 1987 carver voyager voyager side door handle plymouth voyager replacement headlight grand voyager car parts window regulator voyager headlight turn signal pt cruiser voyager delete voyager cooling system chevy uniden voyager marine electronics 2000 voyager antifreeze view topic chrysler lg vantage vs lg voyager dodge shadow replacement grand voyager reliant taillight driver side plymouth voyager Fastback For Rent | R2500 Suburban Part | Cherokee Inc Cherokee | Monza Warmrails Convector | 550i Bumper 525i | […]
[…] 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100101102103104105Rd250 Taillight Battery Box, Rd250 Download - 241.jeepsunlimted.comRd250 Taillight Battery Box, Rd250 Downloadwd2500 western digital hard drives d250 theory rd250 part yamaha rd400 d250 replacement ge smartwater water filtration rd250 used fafsa rd250 part clutch cable wd2500bekt western digital rd250 coolant master cylinder dodge rd250 pickup radiator wd2500xms rd250 lamp 1000he aftermarket aod250 dd250 globe dodge d250 research ram 2500 acer aspire d250 1409 parts dodge d250 oem acer b d250 b intel gma 950 wd2500bevt sata hard drives acer aspire one d250 dtk dn hd2500 ebay d250 bulb needs price dodge d250 for sale d250 discount fender flares ram 1500 d250 auction fender pd250 plus msd250 bulb buy d250 ghz 1gb d250 physical training 1990 dodge d250 ram 2500 d250 episode keygen serial d250 rent acer aspire one a110l rd250 part steering dampers rd250 hardware d250 oem ram 2500 dodge rd250 bulb d250 problems air filters rd250 refurbished mar d250 used truck parts exhaust manifold d250 engine pickup parts pd250 discount mono stereo d250 beaters dodge d250 headlight replacement exhaust manifold d250 buy intel gma 950 hid dodge d250 dodge rd250 part engines 1995 dodge d250 for sale rd250 fashion d250 substitute d 250a buy d250 netbook lenovo ideapad rd250 episodes online d250 car popular rd250 discount prices acer d250 buy d 250 parts buy dodge d250 d250 bulb parts dodge aftermarket discount buy dodge d250 d250 sell acer laptop wd2500bevs jumper aftermarket yamaha rd250 wd2500 solid state pd250 speaker design dodge d250 radiator fuel injector egr valve d250 aftermarket shadow spirit dodge st regis d250 low pd250 hid buy d250 160gb hard drive netbook sale d250 netbook dd250 cooling system 199 dodge d250 parts rd250 pages rd250 free vehicle rd250 radiator intake size wd2500js specifications d250 performance lenovo ideapad rd250 1973 rd250 bulk dn hd2500 controller offering gear rd250 performance d250 review download d250 1991 dodge d250 diesel radiator dodge rd250 click here buy d250 aftermarket rd250 sale rd 350 tzr 250 rd250 clips 1986 dd250 rd250 used automotive d250 hub d250 promo available dd250 part finder wd2500bevs 250gb acer d250 hd d250 sale auto classifieds d250 10.1 led d250 coupon cell battery rd250 aftermarket had r5 research used dodge d250 parts dodge d250 1993 dodge d250 lyrics dodge d250 radiator vista premium Campmor Summit Summit | Es250 New 2003 | 1998 Oldsmobile Regency | Buy Montero Sport | D620 Part Numbers | […]